Trader’s Workshop Ep. 523 | Unusual Options Activity, Signal or Hype?

Is unusual options activity a real signal or just hype? Lex, Mark Phillips and the panel say how an order trades matters more than its size, argue for data over anecdotes, and explain why a big print can hide the other side of the trade.


Every trader has seen the post. A giant block of calls goes through, someone screenshots it, and the replies fill up with people sure they know what it means. In episode 523 of The Brew, the Trader’s Workshop edition from the Tradier Hub, Lex and his panel, including Mark Phillips, sit down on a Wednesday to ask a plainer question. Is unusual options activity a real signal, or is it mostly hype?

They start with size and quickly set it aside. A big print isn’t unusual just because it’s big. Fifty thousand contracts in a name that rarely trades sounds dramatic, but if it lands the day before a dividend, it’s probably someone running a dividend play and nothing more. What interests the panel more is how an order gets executed. Someone lifting offers aggressively, hitting bids, or working several strikes in the same direction tells you more than raw contract count. As one of them puts it, the how matters more than the how much.

The next layer is context, and this is where the group gets skeptical. A call trade printing near the ask doesn’t have to be bullish. It could be someone closing a short, rolling a position, or building one leg of a larger structure, and a retail trader looking at the tape usually can’t tell which. The panel keeps coming back to the other side of the trade. Mark gives an example of a large holder selling a nine-month call against their shares. That’s a classic overwrite and easy to hedge, so it doesn’t scare him. Cheap, out-of-the-money, short-dated calls from someone who might know something worry him far more. One panelist shares a time an unusual trade did pay off, after it showed up in their volatility data and the context around it made sense.

They want data, too. Mark says he has never seen analysis showing that a trade some percentage above daily volume leads to a particular result, and that he operates on data analysis first. Without clear parameters for what counts as unusual, he says, the idea has merit only in quotes. The panel carves out one exception. Biotech is where unusual activity feels most pertinent. Heavy put buying ahead of a drug decision is the kind of footprint that gets attention, because there’s a specific event and a plausible reason someone would pay up for protection.

So what should a retail trader do with a flag like that? The panel’s answer is that the flag is where the work begins. Look at the chain and see where skew sits, whether the upside has a bias, and whether the tails look fat. Mark tells a story about someone in cyber security who wanted an AI agent to predict which way stocks would go. His advice was to start with what you know. A person who understands that industry already has an edge over most of the people trading its stocks.

Viewer mail pulls it together. Someone asks how much confidence to put in two million dollars of out-of-the-money calls bought ahead of earnings. The panel’s answer is not much, because you can’t see whether those contracts were opened or closed, and there’s no free source that shows it cleanly. You have to know what you don’t know.

In the closing minutes, one panelist notes that futures options had just been released in their tools, with volatility surfaces and Greek aggregations, and Lex mentions that the new Hub website is coming along. Mark points viewers to The Till on Substack, and the show signs off with the usual happy trading.

Options involve risk. This episode is educational and not a recommendation.

About Trader’s Workshop / The Brew

Trader’s Workshop is a recurring segment within The Brew on Tradier Hub where Lex, Mark, and Jason engage with audience questions and work through live market setups including major earnings events.



Leave a Reply


Recommended for You

Create a free account, or log in.

Gain access to read this article, plus limited free content.

Yes, I would like to receive top content, special offers, and other updates.