Market WineDown Ep. 12 — Buying Volatility, Finding Options Edge & The Power of Collars

Mark and Lex break down why collars are having a moment on richly valued, high-volatility names, with a nod to Mark Cuban's famous Yahoo collar. Guest Chris Roland, a former actuary turned full-time options trader, discusses buying premium over selling it, disciplined position sizing across 30 to 70 trades, and having no clean exit formula.

The opening bell this week is a deep dive on collars, a trade Mark calls unfashionable until suddenly it isn’t. The mechanics are simple — buy a downside put, sell an upside call against long stock — but Mark and Lex spend real time on why the trade is having a moment right now: with implied volatility elevated on richly valued names and interest rates where they are, the risk-reward on collaring a high-beta stock has gotten unusually favorable. They cite a Micron example from an earlier workshop session where a 25-delta put paired with something like a 40-to-45-delta call produced nearly four times as much upside room as downside protection, a function of how skewed volatility gets priced on high-beta names. Lex also tells the story of Mark Cuban’s famous Yahoo collar with Goldman Sachs — locking in a chunk of his Broadcast.com windfall before the stock fell from the $150s to under $25 — as a real-world reminder that collars aren’t just a textbook concept.

The guest segment features Chris Roland, a former life actuary turned full-time options trader, whose path into the markets started from an unusual angle: pricing index annuities and watching how the banks hedging those products were distorting pricing in things like European dividend futures. That observation — that structural, price-insensitive flow moves markets in predictable ways — became the foundation of his trading approach. Chris describes splitting options traders into two camps: the purely statistical, edge-driven type, and the retail trader using options mainly as a directional tool. He places himself closer to the first camp, generally buying premium and building conviction from a combination of a market thesis and a read on whether the options chain looks mispriced relative to it.

The conversation gets specific on portfolio construction: Chris typically runs thirty to seventy positions at once, deliberately sized so no single idea can do outsized damage — out-of-the-money option positions capped around two percent of the book, in-the-money positions up to five or ten percent — leaning on the law of large numbers rather than any one high-conviction bet. He’s candid that he tried selling premium and found it too stressful to sustain, preferring to sit in cash waiting for a genuinely underpriced setup rather than collecting steady theta. On exits, his answer is refreshingly honest: there’s no clean formula, just portfolio-level volatility monitoring, a bias toward trimming winners before round-tripping them, and a rule about not letting a losing stretch snowball, since he sees his own returns as serially correlated in both directions.

Mark and Lex close out with their usual speed round — Chris naming Vega as his favorite Greek and George Soros as his hypothetical dinner guest — and a Beyond the Bell segment that wanders into golf-course phone etiquette and a very expensive bottle of Sine Qua Non from Lex’s cellar. It’s a lighter episode on structure than some, but the collar discussion alone is worth the watch for anyone sitting on appreciated stock and wondering how to protect it without selling outright.


Coming soon!


Leave a Reply


Recommended for You

Create a free account, or log in.

Gain access to read this article, plus limited free content.

Yes, I would like to receive top content, special offers, and other updates.